Review of: Footfall
Book by:
Larry Niven and Jerry Pournelle

Reviewed by:
Rating:
3
On September 24, 2017
Last modified:October 19, 2017

Summary:

It’s a lot of fun to read, there are some fascinating insights into interstellar travel, generation ships and so on. The strengths of the authors clearly lie in the area of science, and tellingly, the scientific theories of the time, take Bussard Ramjets as an example. The attempt to demonstrate how alien the aliens are by using a herd mentality is interesting. The usage of elephants is probably to help us imagine a secondary race becoming the apex predator of Earth if we became extinct. Would it be possible for another species on Earth to evolve and take over for example? An enjoyable read minus how outdated some of the attitudes and science seems.

Footfall by Larry Niven and Jerry Pournelle

This is my review of Footfall, a Larry Niven and Jerry Pournelle novel from 1985. Overall, the story is of a race of elephant-like aliens from Alpha Centauri invading Earth and Earth’s attempts at repelling the invasion. You can buy it here: http://amzn.to/2fiB0Sz

Footfall, what’s it about?

When Footfall was published in 1985, it was a fairly well received alien invasion novel. Footfall was nominated for the 1986 Hugo Award for Best Novel and the 1986 Locus Award for Best Science Fiction Novel and was a No. 1 New York Times Bestseller. The Larry Niven and Jerry Pournelle pedigree certainly helped this happen. Overall, the story is of a race of elephant-like aliens from Alpha Centauri invading Earth and Earth’s attempts at repelling the invasion.

Human characters, and there are lots, consist of civilians who are preppers, military who give us stereotypical performances and Russians stepped straight out of a 1950’s cold war fiction novel. The female characters who are so badly written they are insulting with many only concerned with how some men will think of them.

Science fiction writers are placed as advisers which is simultaneously a great and awful move, something I’d label as Schrodinger’s characterization. Seriously, sci-fi writers including sci-fi writers? Are sci-fi writers the only people with imagination? As some are based on the authors it appears so.

Back to the story, the initial assault is global however the landing point is Kansas. It’s not really memorable as to why the Fithp chose to settle in Kansas but the reason is neither here nor there as both the Americans and Russians nuke the alien base there anyway. Utterly horrified by the pollution of the garden region of America (as yes that was the reason) the Fithp throw an asteroid at the Indian Ocean and destroy India and much of that region. Running out of continents, the Fithp now choose to invade Africa and actually get help doing this by promising influence to local “warlords”.

Meanwhile, back in the famous Cheyenne Mountain Complex, a plan is hatched to launch an atomic bomb powered ship from the preppers town to take on the alien mothership. The propulsion was based on a real idea, check out Project Orion. Some things happen and there’s some conclusion reached but the end is rather sudden.

Video review of Footfall

Anything going for this?

Yes, it’s a lot of fun to read, there are some fascinating insights into interstellar travel, generation ships and so on. The strengths of the authors clearly lie in the area of science, and tellingly, the scientific theories of the time, take Bussard Ramjets as an example. The attempt to demonstrate how alien the aliens are by using a herd mentality is interesting. The usage of elephants is probably to help us imagine a secondary race becoming the apex predator of Earth if we became extinct. Would it be possible for another species on Earth to evolve and take over for example?

Tons of characters, not sure why as some seem very similar to each other. As there’s a cast of thousands it gives the book a “big” feel to it but the substance is missing. It could be a great TV series though, a single season show if it was updated to have a more modern outlook and some what I consider to be glaring errors were corrected. Project Orion never really took off literally because of the fallout so another drive system could be selected. That’s just an example.

Anyway, an enjoyable read minus how outdated some of the attitudes and science seems.

You can watch and subscribe to StarfleetComms on YouTube or listen and subscribe to StarfleetComms on Stitcher Radio and Player FM! Please remember to vote and review us.

Thank you very much for listening or watching our science fiction podcast

We really appreciate that you took time out of your day to visit. Feel free to comment or contact us on social media such as our YouTube channel, Facebook, Twitter, Google +, use the contact form or email us using [email protected] We'd love to hear from you, your comments might even be on the show!

Thank you for the podcast reviews!

Your written podcast reviews encourage us and they help other people find the podcast. If you appreciate the podcast, please write your own review on iTunes, Stitcher or UK Podcasters!

Liked it? Take a second to support StarfleetComms on Patreon!

Comments are closed.

© 2017 StarfleetComms